Season 5 marks a certain unique period of growth in the series, and it's something you could tell right from the first episode. Unlike the season 4 vibe of "moving on from high school to college," Buffy vs. Dracula is more focused on Buffy's maturity as a Slayer, with Giles admitting that she has become wiser and stronger that she very well might not need him anymore. Naturally, by the end of it, this is proven to be not true in a very heartwarming moment that's definitely a highlight moment in the series.
I like this development. For much of season 4, Giles (along with Xander) has been sitting around being treated as the elderly facing midlife crisis. This development in the season 5 opener gives us the reminder of Giles' significance among the Scoobies, Giles the Mind.
I love Dracula and the other Universal Monster Trio, and I think this crossover was a matter of time. Many superheroes have gone against Dracula, from Spider-Man to Batman, so the Vampire Slayer has to have this one encounter with the vampire of legends. Unfortunately, he turns out to be something of a joke, but it's not surprising considering whom he's up against. Dracula is just among the many who underestimates the Slayer's powers (see the equally cheesy Sunday from "The Freshman"). That said, I love that Marti Noxon really played up all the familiar vampire tropes associated with Dracula; turning into mist, turning into a wolf, turning into a bat, hypnosis, etc. But in hindsight, it makes Dracula feel like such a drama queen, prettying up his entrance instead of getting down to it. Bonus points for the Lestat reference as well.
Speaking of references, Xander wins the best joke of the episode: "
Also, where did you get that accent? Sesame Street? Von, two, three! Three victims! Mah-ha-ha-ha!" Ouch! Somebody get Dracula a wet towel for that burn.
As with season 4, Xander is becoming more likable than the first three (even if he still has that childish fetish for Willow's relationship with Tara). It's so Xander in these later seasons to remain pleasant while under Dracula's thrall:
"I'm supposed to deliver you to the Master now. There's this whole deal where I get to be immortal. You cool with that?" Bonus points for Xander acknowledging his long-running status as a butt-monkey. Whether if the writers would decrease the usage of such a tired trope remains to be seen.
Other characters would still remain the same this episode without any growth or maturity... namely Riley:
"I couldn't believe the first 20 times you told us, but it's starting to sink in now."
"What with Angel, it's understandable that there would be transference."
"But you are NOT going anywhere near (Dracula) again."
And there's the passive-aggressive misogynist I loathe so much. Welcome back, I guess. Could you please leave? Like forever? Like never return to the series this or the next season? Pretty please with a cherry on top? Sigh.
To be fair, the other male characters were also under the influence of jealousy as well, so Dracula might have simply amplified the inherent toxicity within Riley up to eleven. Who knows with Dracula lore? It's so arbitrary. Like is Dracula going to stay as mist for the rest of the series? Oh well.
I also hated this line from Riley:
"If the Initiative was still around, we would have been able to find everything in a few hours." I'm sorry, but you lost me at "If the Initiative was still around." Do you have rocks for brains, Riley? Initiative, evil, remember? It's like Captain America saying,
"Boy oh boy, if only the HYDRA-infiltrated S.H.I.E.L.D was still around!" 🙄
Something of a return to form that I like is Willow becoming computer-savvy again. While she did do some hacking in season 4, those moments were far and few between, so I'm hoping we get more of these moments to show Willow's smartness with both magic and technology.
Also, beginning this season, every of Joyce's dialogue feels like it would be a foreshadow to "The Body". What little dialogue she has in this episode feels like it's building up on the loss of connection between her and the Scoobies, with her voicing out about her loneliness and her own midlife crisis.
Overall, a fun season opener, but not one that says as much about the characters as the other openers, especially "The Freshman". In fact, I would rank this above Freshman just for being far more fun, and also how it introduces us to the darker elements behind Buffy's Slayer powers.
Final Rating: 7/10
Next episode...
Oh boy.