Do Vengence Demons Have Souls

NoShip

Scooby
Joined
Feb 12, 2023
Messages
1,336
Age
56
Several posters bring up Anya's soul as a reason for Buffy to kill her in Selfless. Others claim that Anya is responsible for her atrocities as a demon because she had a soul.

As far as I can tell, the presence or absence of a soul in Vengence Demons is never mentioned in the show.

So......

1. Do Vengence Demons have souls? Why or Why Not.

2. If 'YES' - What is the nature of said soul?
For example: do they keep their human soul? Do they receive a Demon soul?
 
Reason: Spelling & Grammar
Several posters bring up Anya's soul as a reason for Buffy to kill her in Selfless. Others claim that Anya is responsible for her atrocities as a demon because she had a soul.

As far as I can tell, the presence or absence of a soul in Vengence Demons is never mentioned in the show.

So......

1. Do Vengence Demons have souls? Why or Why Not.

2. If 'YES' - What is the nature of said soul?
For example: do they keep their human soul? Do they receive a Demon soul?

When she was Aud, she had a soul (she loved bunnies then lol).

Therefore, I'm assuming that TPTB saw all the good Anyanka had accomplished with the Scoobies and gave her soul back. That's my take on it.
 
I'm going to say that at the time of Selfless Anya had a soul because she had the capacity to recognize that she'd done something wrong by murdering the frat boys and wanted to take it back.

This only goes to show how messed up soul canon is in the show, largely thanks to Spike. If it requires a soul for someone to recognise they did something wrong, Spike was absolutely incapable of recognising he did anything wrong to Buffy and never went to get a soul. Heck, he didn't even admit he'd really done something wrong with a soul. So, the ability to recognise doing something wrong would not therefore lead to confirmation she had a soul - if Spike could do that without a soul. Anya's and Spike's behaviour do not match up.
 
These are my answers on the OP's questions.

1. Vengeance demons do have souls. When D'Hoffryn recruits Anya, we don't see any change in her personality. When he tries to recruit Willow, he does not ask her to make any changes. In this world, atrocities are committed by people with souls with no need for demon insertion, so although there is no explicit statement in canon, I assume souls are not changed. What is not shown to the applicants is that they cannot take back anything they do without a penalty of some sort, like the death of Halfreq.

2. The soul is exactly the same as before.
 
  1. Yes, Vengeance Demons aren't true demons, they are transformed into demons after entering a satanic pact, in this case, Aud sold her soul to D'hoffryn. It's more like Hellraiser, where the Cenobites started off as humans, were tortured, then reborn into their current personas, but only after being physically and mentally broken and reconstructed.
  2. It's also worth remembering that Aud was a practioner of black magic. She may be either damned for her actions, or damned in order to undertake her actions, and D just picked up the contract on the open market. Damnation usually plays a fairly major role in undeath, the Devil farming out his captives as a kind of a work release program generally explains a lot, especially if the waters of Lethe exist in this world. But, bottom line, corrupted human soul.
  3. As for Demonic souls, I tend to think of the more Lovecraftian Demons using a Hindu inspired paradigm. The Great Old Ones were able to take a fragment of their own life force, and use it to combine with lower animals, to create an orc race, one that can survive in the middle realms. An individual demon is just lake water in a jar, it normally would return to the oversoul after death, unless you know a guy. But they don't conceive of metaphysics the same way we do, they do not see themselves as eternal individuals, just a permutation of a larger thing. But whatever a demon's soul is, it doesn't have the same metaphorical importance to the conscience.
  4. It's important to remember that the watchers don't care about the metaphysics of the soul, beyond what they learned in Time Life Books Mysteries of the Unknown; The Search for the Soul. Or at least, they don't know any more than we do. What they really care about is the truth about vampires, that they only present themselves as men, but the true essence is a monster that dresses like a man. Failure to accept that truth gets people killed. So, when someone speaks of the Soul on this show, it's just speculation about how the thing might work.
  5. Of course, Mr. Trick has soul, just not a soul.
 
ILLYRIAN
ILLYRIAN
Do what? When does it state in the show about Time Life books? Making loose comparisons is okayish, but thats about it.
When D'Hoffryn recruits Anya, we don't see any change in her personality.
Absolutely true. When Olaf said, "It is no wonder that the bar matrons talk of you," The look on her face was demonic, despite the fact that she was still human.

Once he realized his hasty words had pissed her off, he tried to explain himself, "It is not my fault they don't take kindly to you. You speak your mind, and are annoying. It's one of the things I love most about you."
 
I'm going to say that at the time of Selfless Anya had a soul because she had the capacity to recognize that she'd done something wrong by murdering the frat boys and wanted to take it back.

Good point.
It seems vengeance demons would have their souls. But how would they function doing what they do for decades/hundreds/thousands of years with a soul?

Just a thought that occurred to me - if they do have their souls, perhaps once the wish is granted, the demon part of themselves takes over. Almost like an 'out of body' experience, so they're able to perform the gruesome requests.

Unfortunately, it's all speculation from us because I don't think it's ever confirmed in the series on the soul-status of a vengeance demon.
 
If a character in the show does or does not have a soul can the soul be seen?
Where does it say in the TV show BTVS that Aud was a Black Witch?
When you say Aud was damned for her actions or damned in order to undertake her actions. And, Damnation usually plays a fairly major role in undeath are you referring to the show?
Its okay to make vague comparisons between life and the TV series but please, try not to go into cuckoo land, the Devil does not exist in the TV series in fact, is there a supreme entity in the First?
 
Last edited:
What is a soul anyway?

Not a metaphysical question, but in the Buffyverse, what is a soul? This is never made clear. The closest it seems to be is a conscience that a possessor may or may not listen to. There were certainly enough examples of humans with souls who behaved in evil ways to make possession of a soul irrelevant to whether or not someone is a good person.
 

The Paranormal was a big deal in the 1990s, shows like Buffy X-Files and Millennium grew out of that. That Mysteries was some sort of important text in a world entering into a new awareness of the paranormal seems reasonable. I also like this early idea that the Watchers are myopic, they know a lot about killing vampires, but should big foot show up during a fight, they would be clueless.

Cenobites are a group of torture demons from the Hellraiser movies. Technically, they aren't from hell, and they aren't demons, but broad strokes, torture demons. But, they start off as humans who desire the pleasures of hell and get transformed into immortal torture demons to properly enjoy them. Which is a complicated way to say that Anya was a transformed into a demon, not unlike Cordelia in season 3, except not as stupid.
 
Both Aud and Willow had souls when they did the acts that called down D'hoffryn to offer them the job. I don't actually see any reason they'd stop having them. The fact that Anya was seriously bothered by her actions in the frathouse suggests that she can feel guilt. This seems to be something people with souls experience.

Of all the demons, only vampires are shown to be dead and deemed 'soulless' in the buffyverse. While many demons are considered evil (want to harm/control humans), we don't hear them spoken of as specifically being soulless. Just dangerous and willing to hurt humans to get whatever their agenda is accomplished. Since humans are often also willing to hurt humans to get their agenda accomplished, I am not convinced that lack of a soul is a prerequisite for being deemed 'demon'.

Evil is evil. Some evil is human. Some evil is demon. Animal violence is rarely considered 'evil' even when lethal because animals aren't considered capable of deciding between right and wrong.

Being evil requires some MORAL AGENCY - it is a choice. It does not require the absence of a soul, though the absence of a soul makes it much easier to choose to do 'evil' as one has no capacity to feel guilt if one has no soul (at least that's the case in the buffyverse).


Humans usually know right from wrong and mostly (we are told) try to do 'right'. Evil humans choose to do wrong. Some are considered sociopathic/psychopathic -- and deemed to lack human empathy. They know that things are wrong. They simply don't or can't care.

Demons don't always seem to have a moral compass but only vampires are outright stated to be amoral (incapable of discerning/or simply don't care about) right or wrong. It seems that vampires are the sociopaths of the demon worlds.

Although vengeance demons do things most humans consider evil, they actually do seem to be motivated by some sort of trickster justice. Their "morality" isn't so much absent as skewed (at least by most human standards). They respond when humans are in pain. They mete out 'justice' or 'vengeance' based on the wish of humans. Most of those humans aren't fully cognizant of the potential endpoint of those wishes, but some (probably most) of those wishes aren't pleasant.

Do all sentient creatures have souls? That's a big question. I have no idea.

Since we (writers and creators of fictional universes) are making up mythology -- as far as I know, demons and vampires are not real -- I guess it depends on the writers of the universe in particular. Oddly, i cannot recall many supernatural books that stated that 'no soul was present' in demon x or y.

Demons seem to be on a sliding scale of 'bad' to 'world ending evil'. Some demons aren't even considered 'evil' they are just supernatural beings, mostly with some kind of power that is "more than" human/animal. Most of us in the western world don't like the idea of cats as food, but other than that, there's no evidence that Clem did anything 'evil'. Many animals including most humans, eat other animals. I often find it interesting which animals are considered prey (food) and which animals are considered family (pets) and which animals are considered somewhere in between (things like rabbits seem to straddle that line, occasionally pigs, some birds and other small mammals). In many countries horse meat is considered acceptable. People also keep horses as work animals or pets.

So... if what we eat doesn't make us evil. What constitutes evil? Is it simply that humans believe they're to be at the top of the food chain, and anything that wants to rule/kill them is 'evil'?

  • Sentient beings that kill or hurt humans and have 'powers' are demons and usually considered evil?
  • Sentient human appearing beings that kill or hurt humans and have no powers are 'evil humans'?
  • Non-sentient beings that kill or hurt humans are 'dangerous predator' animals?

What is sentience exactly? Where do you draw the line regarding 'powers?

The buffyverse vampires are stated to have no souls unless otherwise advised. I'm not actually sure there's much about other vampires. Mostly, demons that hurt humans are considered 'evil' -- but there are a lot of different worlds out there and a lot of different variants on the theme. Since Buffy, more vampires appear to have soul/no soul as a thing... but before that, I don't really see a lot about it.

It seems that death is the reason for the loss of souls in vampires -- as anything that has died has been deemed to have lost its soul... does this mean humans who are resuscitated are soulless or is proper death (no electrical activity in brain or heart type death) required for soul to depart?

Since vampires are the only demon whose creation requires death, it makes sense that they alone would not have souls.


I'm not claiming to be an expert nor have i read all the extant theory or supernatural fiction.
 
ILLYRIAN
ILLYRIAN
Thanks
Back
Top Bottom