Should the series have ended when season 6 was over?

silvermoon

Potential
Joined
May 29, 2021
Messages
327
Sorry if this has been touched upon before. I remember reading an article where the writer said they felt Buffy ended naturally in season 6. Season 7 was disliked by a lot of people. I enjoyed parts of it personally. But would it have made sense to end the series at the conclusion of 6?
 
Actually, I think it was season 5 where it was said that it ended naturally. Because they had five seasons planned and it didn't get renewed by the original. It was season six that was the most utterly hated season, though seven wasn't popular either.
 
DeepBlueJoy
DeepBlueJoy
I actually think season 6 was in some ways the most creative season. Other than the trio. That i could have missed. And killing Tara.
No, I don't think Season Six is the note the series should have ended on. Season Six had way too much emotional baggage that had to be sorted out. Granted, I don't really think Season 7 was a great ending for Buffy. At best, it kind of resolved the central tension of the series, does the Slayer's fight have to be a solo one? I didn't think the answer of "We'll remake the watcher's council, only this time it will be matriarchal and have less regard for the girls' lives?" resonated as well as some other season finale's did.
 
No. The story was not over. I don't love season 7 but it brings us to a closing. The writing was far from perfect but it was necessary.

Truthfully it is only bad because it was Buffy. Buffy was so much better than other shows that even a 'poor' buffy season is still good compared to other TV. Chosen was actually a decent final episode.

I am really glad the series did not end with a dead slayer. That would have been a lousy message. The Gift was one hell of an episode but it was a tragedy.

The message of Buffy was to subvert the status quo. Blonde girl goes into the alley and the monsters DON'T get her.

Buffy the trope breaker (and new trope maker)!

Season 7 was poorly executed but i believe in this message: ARE YOU READY TO BE STRONG?!

I believe in Buffy.
 
Last edited:
S6 would've been a really downbeat and confusing way to end the series, with all the characters at a low ebb. Despite it's...many, many problems, S7 gives satisfying character resolutions whilst leaving room for more stories to tell.

I love Buffy as a character but little of that has anything to do with S7, where the writing forces her to doubles down on every single of her character flaws, find a few new ones and regress for a good part of the season so Spike can come along, tell her he believes in her no matter what, and she can save the day. Those last two episodes are pretty great.

And whilst, yes, she needed no one but two McGuffins to do that her epiphany about how to win nicely set-up; Faith showed her that the 'one girl in all the world' rule can be bent' so she realized that, with Willow's help, Buffy could break it.
Leading to a somewhat nonsensical but emotionally uplifting finale; I've seen better show resolutions but I've also seen many, many worse ways to conclude a character's journey.
And most of the other characters get better resolutions thanks to that last season, or at the very least they're better than what S6 gave them.

So I much prefer the ending of S7...but getting there was rough and could've been done a hell of a lot better.
 
Season six was just awful and would have been an awful way to end the series. However, I hate season seven because it made me hate Buffy herself and I will never forgive the season for that. It is only looking back on it that I realise that Spike should be the true target for my hatred in that season for what his horrific three-season abuse had turned Buffy into, a monster she never recovered from. The Gift may have been a bit of a downer, but Buffy did die a hero, saving the world, something she never did again. If she died after season 7, she is not going back to heaven.
 
I don't see Season 6 as a Buffy ending. At the end, Xander saves Willow from ending the world and Buffy is in a graveyard facing off against revitalized dead people alongside of Dawn until Willow ends her reign of terror and the dead go back to being motionless. Willow has lured us into thinking she is a social underdog and worthy of our support only to show that she is a megalomaniac at heart, but that is not about Buffy. If the series was "Willow the Magician" rather than "Buffy the Vampire Slayer", it might have been an acceptable ending. It would have even been better if it was "Xander the Saviour" but that was not what the series was about. BtVS had a feminist message and this would have been totally undermining to make Xander the star.

So no, Buffy could not have ended at the end of Season 6. Seasons 1, 3, 5 and 7 were natural endings.
 
NotASlayer
NotASlayer
Seasons six was essentially "Willow the Wicked Witch" and season seven "Spike the Slayer Layer". Neither was really a great ending for a series called "Buffy the Vampire Slayer".
T
thrasherpix
The last scene of Buffy and Dawn is in a very colorful and sunny green area (like a hallmark card) to music and low singing. Now Buffy leads Dawn into a bright future. It was ironically one of the most sugarcoated endings to a Buffy season.
I don't see Season 6 as a Buffy ending. At the end, Xander saves Willow from ending the world and Buffy is in a graveyard facing off against revitalized dead people alongside of Dawn until Willow ends her reign of terror and the dead go back to being motionless. Willow has lured us into thinking she is a social underdog and worthy of our support only to show that she is a megalomaniac at heart, but that is not about Buffy. If the series was "Willow the Magician" rather than "Buffy the Vampire Slayer", it might have been an acceptable ending. It would have even been better if it was "Xander the Saviour" but that was not what the series was about. BtVS had a feminist message and this would have been totally undermining to make Xander the star.

So no, Buffy could not have ended at the end of Season 6. Seasons 1, 3, 5 and 7 were natural endings.


Season 2 and 6 would have been the most depressing ending possible. And season 4 would have been the most "What? it's ending?" ending possible
 
S6 would've been a really downbeat and confusing way to end the series, with all the characters at a low ebb. Despite it's...many, many problems, S7 gives satisfying character resolutions whilst leaving room for more stories to tell.

I love Buffy as a character but little of that has anything to do with S7, where the writing forces her to doubles down on every single of her character flaws, find a few new ones and regress for a good part of the season so Spike can come along, tell her he believes in her no matter what, and she can save the day. Those last two episodes are pretty great.

And whilst, yes, she needed no one but two McGuffins to do that her epiphany about how to win nicely set-up; Faith showed her that the 'one girl in all the world' rule can be bent' so she realized that, with Willow's help, Buffy could break it.
Leading to a somewhat nonsensical but emotionally uplifting finale; I've seen better show resolutions but I've also seen many, many worse ways to conclude a character's journey.
And most of the other characters get better resolutions thanks to that last season, or at the very least they're better than what S6 gave them.

So I much prefer the ending of S7...but getting there was rough and could've been done a hell of a lot better.
all the responses are good but yours resonates with me in particular as i basically agree . the ending was a bit weird with the crone who apparently was around all this time but nobody ever knew it. just felt like the writers pulled it out of their azzes a bit. the spike/buffy stuff for me was spectacular. still pissed they killed off anya even though apparently emma wanted that. xander was very emotionless when he said 'that's my girl' which still makes me scratch my head. but hey pobody's nerfect
 
Well, it could work. If we are going with the Dark Phoenix/Star Wars Skywalker Saga adaptation, Andrew, Jonathan, Anya and Giles die. Dawn gets undone. wounded Xander gets through to Willow, who dies trying to stop the She-Demon. Buffy is the only survivor. We last see her checking into a Watcher Safehouse.
 
the ending was a bit weird with the crone who apparently was around all this time but nobody ever knew it. just felt like the writers pulled it out of their azzes a bit.

It struck me as weird that she called Buffy 'the last guardian of the Hellmouth'. Um, were there others? When was the 1st one? Were they all slayers like Buffy? Were they around whilst there was a Sunnydale and/or before?
*scratches head* ...anyways, at least she explained where the cool axe/scythe thing came from.
 
It struck me as weird that she called Buffy 'the last guardian of the Hellmouth'. Um, were there others? When was the 1st one? Were they all slayers like Buffy? Were they around whilst there was a Sunnydale and/or before?
*scratches head* ...anyways, at least she explained where the cool axe/scythe thing came from.

I think the Chumash should count and even though he was using it to set up something Wilkins should count
 
It was stated that the principal of Sunnydale Highs mother was a slayer (in New York) and that she was killed by Spike. Was there any mention that she knew anything about the Hellmouth being in Sunnydale and if so why not?

Buffy only came to Sunnydale as a result of the vampire attack on the school she was at, was there a hellmouth near there.

Where had the previous Hellmouths been?
Western America
Eastern America
China
Given that a slayer is born in each generation even though when one dies another is born you might think that more should have been known about the Hellmouths . . . or it is that my memory has gotten really bad.
 
the spike/buffy stuff for me was spectacular.

And I loathe the love letter to stalkers and abusers that is Spuffy. I hate the misogyny implicit in how Spike's wishes for a relationship are treated as more important than Buffy's desires, and how his abuse turned a strong, independent woman into a pathetic, mewling, unlikeable mess whose only role was to be a cheerleader for Spike. Spike is a classic abuser, charming and manipulative, and if he looked like the Master the number of people romanticising his treatment of Buffy would fall off a cliff.

Yes, Buffy and Spike have chemistry. But Spike has chemistry with anyone he is on screen with. As has been pointed out before, Spike would have chemistry with a stick. You could write fanfic in which Spike charms a stake.
 
hoponlilmama
hoponlilmama
Indeed, Spuffy fans will say it's brilliant writing. It isn't.
DeepBlueJoy
DeepBlueJoy
Someone wrote a story where Spike copulated with a desk! Yes they did. Yes it was posted on tthfanfic!
I think the Chumash should count

The Chumash were peaceful, weren't they?
Tbh I'd have preferred if the last 'woman watching the watchers' or whatever the hell she was called, was Native American priestess or something rather than someone out of Arthurian myth.

even though he was using it to set up something Wilkins should count

Good point. The Mayor did provide stability around the Hellmouth for a time; for his own selfish ends obviously.
And I'd posit he stopped The Master's scheme to unleash the Old Ones back in the 30's with a well-timed earthquake. Plus there was a satanic cult/temple that was also swallowed by the earth.
 
NotASlayer
NotASlayer
You'd kind of think that W&H might have stepped in afterwards and taken over the Mayor's fronts to help keep a lid on things.
And I loathe the love letter to stalkers and abusers that is Spuffy. I hate the misogyny implicit in how Spike's wishes for a relationship are treated as more important than Buffy's desires, and how his abuse turned a strong, independent woman into a pathetic, mewling, unlikeable mess whose only role was to be a cheerleader for Spike. Spike is a classic abuser, charming and manipulative, and if he looked like the Master the number of people romanticising his treatment of Buffy would fall off a cliff.

Yes, Buffy and Spike have chemistry. But Spike has chemistry with anyone he is on screen with. As has been pointed out before, Spike would have chemistry with a stick. You could write fanfic in which Spike charms a stake.
Point taken. I think he had a redemption arc and got his soul back then sacrificed himself to save the world. People always ignore that bit . But to each their own.
 
hoponlilmama
hoponlilmama
Well, Buffy sent Angel away, so it would've been him. And redemption - doesn't it bother you he never even apologised for raping her in Dead Things and the attempted rape in SR?
Point taken. I think he had a redemption arc and got his soul back then sacrificed himself to save the world. People always ignore that bit . But to each their own.

Well, I don't ignore it; it is just that Spike's redemption arc starts partway through Angel S5. Until then, he was still the same old obsessed, narcissistic abuser who accidentally blew himself up trying to get laid. He victim-blamed Buffy, never once showed that he had any interest in getting himself a soul to improve himself before, during or after getting one, actively made everyone's lives more difficult by refusing to do help them remove the First's influence, as well as ensuring that Buffy was dependent on only him, not anyone else, just like a good abuser would.

It took seeing Hell with a soul and getting his hands chopped off for Spike to start redeeming himself and actually take responsibility for his actions. After that, he had a good redemption arc.
 
Back
Top Bottom