Should the series have ended when season 6 was over?

Put me in the camp of those who say it should end with 5. And if you don't want to end on Buffy's death as a bad thing. You could have Willow start a resurrection, realize where she is (Heaven, or one of them anyway), and connect the others so they all KNOW she's in a better place.
 
NotASlayer
NotASlayer
Or falling through the portal rips the Slayer out of Buffy, saving her from the fall and leaving her alive and human.
Well, I don't ignore it; it is just that Spike's redemption arc starts partway through Angel S5. Until then, he was still the same old obsessed, narcissistic abuser who accidentally blew himself up trying to get laid. He victim-blamed Buffy, never once showed that he had any interest in getting himself a soul to improve himself before, during or after getting one, actively made everyone's lives more difficult by refusing to do help them remove the First's influence, as well as ensuring that Buffy was dependent on only him, not anyone else, just like a good abuser would.

It took seeing Hell with a soul and getting his hands chopped off for Spike to start redeeming himself and actually take responsibility for his actions. After that, he had a good redemption arc.
the soul taking responsibility for the demon's actions is the worst part of the Buffyverse. It's nonsensical

But as for Spike never showing he wanted one, blame the writers cause they wanted a twist. Apparently him saying he was going to give Buffy what she deserved was meant to be literal and his anger was equivalent of those videos where people make positive choices for themselves and hate having to do it .

Because it's canon he went for the soul

Put me in the camp of those who say it should end with 5. And if you don't want to end on Buffy's death as a bad thing. You could have Willow start a resurrection, realize where she is (Heaven, or one of them anyway), and connect the others so they all KNOW she's in a better place.

Heaven for a 20 year old who started out the show not wanting a short life is not a better place no matter how nice it was
 
Wait, wait. We have been watching the same show, and you expect world building with the Egyptian Temple Custodians who literally came out of nowhere? A sword purchased in an NES game that was hacked by a Game Genie has more story behind it than +2 Axe.

Plus, remember Star Trek, Smallville, Supernatural and Flash. The Fifth Network really liked running shows into the ground. Heck, how many cycles of America's Next Top Model were produced? How many produced top models?
 
But as for Spike never showing he wanted one, blame the writers cause they wanted a twist. Apparently him saying he was going to give Buffy what she deserved was meant to be literal and his anger was equivalent of those videos where people make positive choices for themselves and hate having to do it .

Because it's canon he went for the soul

It may be canon, but it is still never backed up in the writing. Sure, blame poor writing, which S6 was riddled with, but even afterwards, he was never shown as wanting one, and his treatment of Buffy after getting a soul was just as bad as his treatment of her before getting one. Actually, worse. Narcissistic obsession and abuse that is done because Spike was a soulless monster is not as bad as narcissistic obsession and abuse with a soul that is done out of choice. What Buffy "deserved" according to Spike was Spike. What she wanted or what would be good for her was utterly irrelevant to a narcissistic abuser.

Whether or not the soul taking responsibility for the demon's actions is nonsensical or not is irrelevant, because it was also canon. Angel was the only vampire with a soul, he took responsibility, therefore this is how it is.

But as @AlphaFoxtrot points out, the show was never great with consistency and it utterly stopped even trying to maintain internal coherence in seasons 6 and 7.
 
Guilt is a powerful emotion so to say things like 'it obviously wasn't them that did those things' when they have a 100+ memories of doing and enjoying those things with the demon who did them still being inside them is baffling.
Normal human beings feel guilty for all kinds of random crap they're not responsible for, all the time. Expecting emotions to be cut and dried based in rational though is, actually, the silly, baffling thing.

Angel and Spike deal with that guilt in different ways; one feels the burden very keenly but he also kind of obsesses over it and wallows in it (not without reason, given his own show) the other compartmentalizes it and builds it into his Big Bad persona that is needed to 'win the day'. Objectively speaking neither way is 'better (leaving aside entertainment value or stary-telling potential)', but they do inform the character that they are and what they value.
 
I'm also in the season 5 camp. Much like Supernatural, it was the natural end of the show and the main character's arc. People prefer a happy ending though, so Buffy dying would've been a bummer note for many. Understandable.

That said, yes, I would have preferred season 6 as a final season if we had to pick between it and season 7.
Season 7 is... I don't even know what it is. I cannot bring myself to rewatch it anymore cause I just think it's a giant mess from start to finish with few if any redeeming qualities.

I hate that the show ended with Buffy forcing the burden she has spent seven years getting crushed under, upon countless and countless of girls in the world. It is a terrible message. And to boot that she does it for little reason at all. It is not the Slayer spell that saves Sunnydale. It's a doohickey Angel brought and Spike wore. So it is ultimately Spike and W&H that saved Sunnydale, not Buffy. Yay? Finally, a man to save the day! Whilst our hero thrust an unspeakable destiny of monsters and horrors on girls globally... yay?

At least by the end of season 6 Buffy is starting to be Buffy again, and it might have been a nice bookend to the series that the two humans she pulled into this crazy world in season 1, ended up simultaneously being the ones who tried to destroy and ended up saving it. It makes the ending more Scooby-centric than season 7 does, which I like.

At the end of season 6 it feels like Buffy is looking towards the future, and yes, one is left with a lot of questions, but one is left with even more questions by the end of season 7. Buffy has at that point paid for her happiness by taking it from others. Yes, there'll be more Slayers to share the burden, but still, she had violated countless of girls without their consent and this is now girl power. Thanks, but no thanks. So yeah, I'll take season 6 as the ending, happily.
 
G
garfan
the burden is so bad because she's alone, but she's not now
That said, yes, I would have preferred season 6 as a final season if we had to pick between it and season 7.
Season 7 is... I don't even know what it is. I cannot bring myself to rewatch it anymore cause I just think it's a giant mess from start to finish with few if any redeeming qualities.

And the First is... incomprehensible. Its actions make zero sense at any point. Consider its use of bombs.

Minion: "Master, we have planted the bomb and destroyed the Watcher council."

The First Evil :"Excellent. And the bomb trap for Faith and the Potentials?"

M: "That is set."

TFE: "Good, good. Many Potentials will die."

M: "Master?"

TFE: "Yes minion?"

M: "Shall I plant a third bomb in the Slayer's house?"

TFE: "Why?"

M: "Well... so we can kill the Slayers and all the Potentials at once?"

TFE: "Sorry? How will that accomplish this? I fail to understand the logic."

M: "Because... blowing the house up with them all in it will kill them all?"

TFE: "Still not getting it."

All finished off with, as you said, Buffy making herself like the Shadow Men, although magnitudes worse, and a finale that, for all the good Buffy and the Scoobies did, they would have been better off spending in Tahiti.

Neither season 6 or 7 is great for a show that is supposed to be about strong female characters. Especially as the two main characters of S7 are Spike and Andrew.

The entire message of Spuffy is that what a woman really needs in life is a man. Her own desires are irrelevant, and anything said man does is perfectly justified because he wants her.
 
Taake
Taake
TFE is really such a crappy villain, lol
I asked a similar question a while back asking if they'd be happy if the series had ended in s5. It's naturally a mixed bag of replies. Some folks aren't pleased with the idea of Buffy dying.

To me, it's evident the series had a thought-out 5-year plan. And whilst sad, it, in some ways is still a beautiful ending. Buffy's at peace, and she's reunited with her mother. She made the ultimate sacrifice and saved the world.

I would've been OK with the series ending at The Gift. I don't hate s6 or s7, but they are VERY problematic, pandering to certain fans and it was clear they didn't have a good plan in place. Shark jumping.
 
@garfan

But that is like saying, the burden is so bad because she is in an isolated cell. Now that she has imprisoned 10 000 other girls, she won't be so burdened/lonely anymore.

But it completely neglects that even with a shared burden, she has hoisted a chain upon thousands of girls who had no say in it. And as we all know, Buffy spends at least five years of the series mostly talking about how she wishes she could have a normal life, how she could be a normal girl, and not have a definite death sentence over her head. So the fact that she liberates herself by condemning others... it is a tough pill to swallow.
 
Guilt is a powerful emotion so to say things like 'it obviously wasn't them that did those things' when they have a 100+ memories of doing and enjoying those things with the demon who did them still being inside them is baffling.
Normal human beings feel guilty for all kinds of random crap they're not responsible for, all the time. Expecting emotions to be cut and dried based in rational though is, actually, the silly, baffling thing.

Yeah, this is something that pops up in sci-fi/fantasy every so often. And vampiric possession isn't even the only example we see in this show. Xander "lived" a future where he ended up killing Anya. And you can argue that it wasn't real, but to him it was. Even if you can convince his head it wasn't him you can't convince his heart. Same thing happened to Miles O'brien in the DS-9 episode "Hard Time". From his perspective he spent 20 years in jail and murdered his cellmate.
 
Guilt is a powerful emotion so to say things like 'it obviously wasn't them that did those things' when they have a 100+ memories of doing and enjoying those things with the demon who did them still being inside them is baffling.
Normal human beings feel guilty for all kinds of random crap they're not responsible for, all the time. Expecting emotions to be cut and dried based in rational though is, actually, the silly, baffling thing.

Angel and Spike deal with that guilt in different ways; one feels the burden very keenly but he also kind of obsesses over it and wallows in it (not without reason, given his own show) the other compartmentalizes it and builds it into his Big Bad persona that is needed to 'win the day'. Objectively speaking neither way is 'better (leaving aside entertainment value or stary-telling potential)', but they do inform the character that they are and what they value.

I have no doubt that they on the personal level should feel the guilt. They do remember doing

The problem I have is that despite knowing the lore of the show not a single person's response to the guilt was "You weren't actually there, you idiot, you had no ability to stop anything or save anyone because you were absent" The closest we get was some people believing they'd changed
 
Actually, I think it was season 5 where it was said that it ended naturally. Because they had five seasons planned and it didn't get renewed by the original. It was season six that was the most utterly hated season, though seven wasn't popular either.
It isn't the "most utterly hated season", unless you unabashedly hate Spike or are an eternal Bangel shipper. But, from talking to many Buffy fans over the years, I can say that it definitely is the most divisive season. What that means, though, is that there are a LOT of people who love it for a variety of reasons.

Personally, I have a peculiar relationship with it because when I first watched it I was dealing with depression and the seasonal arc of Buffy's character was relatable. I think her emotional turmoil resonated with me and so the season helped me go through my own bullshit. 'Once More with Feeling' also kickstarted my passion for singing and the last stretch of the season was insanely emotional. With all that being said, though, watching it back now, it has too many average episodes for me to rank it anywhere above the great seasons of the series.

But seasons 3 and 5 would've been better seasons to end with.
Honestly, I'm content with Buffy ending the way it did. It's one of the rare endings to a show where I have little to complain about. My issues with S7 never involved its conclusion.

If I was forced to pick another stopping point, though, I would definitely go with season 5. I think over 90% of the fans would do the same. It's sad but beautiful and meaningful.
 
It isn't the "most utterly hated season", unless you unabashedly hate Spike or are an eternal Bangel shipper. But, from talking to many Buffy fans over the years, I can say that it definitely is the most divisive season. What that means, though, is that there are a LOT of people who love it for a variety of reasons.

Well, I am neither of those, and I utterly hate it.

By most hated, I mean that it is the season people hate more than any other. Yes, this can also be considered to be divisive, but going by figures @NoShip has quoted, it is the most disliked season.

it has too many average episodes for me to rank it anywhere above the great seasons of the series.

In the first five seasons, even the bad episodes were often memorable. In seasons six and seven, most of them just blend into a bland mess. This is not helped by the fact that Buffy is not one of the most important characters of those seasons; she is merely on screen a lot. Season 6 was about Willow and Spike; season 7 was about Spike and, way behind, Andrew.
Post automatically merged:

@Tome Viewing figures and loss of audience. I pinged @NoShip so that he can hopefully share them again.
 
Last edited:
Tome
Tome
What figures?
The culpability of the soul for the Vampire's deeds is an subjective optical illusion, not a serious moral argument.

Second, Angel is not an theologian or a philosopher. He's a confused vampire who is being manipulated by demons who are slightly less racist to humans. He doesn't have a logically consistent worldview.
 
Point taken. I think he had a redemption arc and got his soul back then sacrificed himself to save the world. People always ignore that bit . But to each their own.
i thought him burning himself in front of her on the cross was definitely a big ol'im sorry i did this to you
 
i thought him burning himself in front of her on the cross was definitely a big ol'im sorry i did this to you
I would classify that as one of the worst moments of the series. Buffy the victim being forced to feel for the man that almost raped her because he puts on a big dramatic pity me scene.

I found it more manipulative than a genuine ”big ol’ I’m sorry” (Which would have included not forcing himself back into Buffy’s life at this point. I’ll always feel he should have been moved to Angel first, then come back to Sunnydale… but obviously this didnt work for story reasons etc. But if they’d had more time, Spike should have given Buffy space, not become her dependant)
 
I would classify that as one of the worst moments of the series. Buffy the victim being forced to feel for the man that almost raped her because he puts on a big dramatic pity me scene.

I found it more manipulative than a genuine ”big ol’ I’m sorry” (Which would have included not forcing himself back into Buffy’s life at this point. I’ll always feel he should have been moved to Angel first, then come back to Sunnydale… but obviously this didnt work for story reasons etc. But if they’d had more time, Spike should have given Buffy space, not become her dependant)

Agreed.

A genuine big ol' I'm sorry would include an actual "I'm sorry" and him leaving rather than "this is all your fault and I refuse to take responsibility for my actions" and staying, then driving Buffy away from her friends. Again.

As it is depicted, this is a perfect illustration of how an obsessed narcissistic abuser would handle the situation.
 
hoponlilmama
hoponlilmama
But, but....Spike is the only one who understands her!! :P
Yeah, the end of Beneath You was just a way to skirt the whole apology portion of getting Buffy and Spike back together; 'he's suffering because you used him now can't we move on?' It's dressed up as a dramatic reveal except the audience already knows the twist so its really a dud of an episode.
Also a puppy died. This episode should not be acknowledged as 'good quality' in any way.
 
Yeah, the end of Beneath You was just a way to skirt the whole apology portion of getting Buffy and Spike back together; 'he's suffering because you used him now can't we move on?' It's dressed up as a dramatic reveal except the audience already knows the twist so its really a dud of an episode.
Also a puppy died. This episode should not be acknowledged as 'good quality' in any way.
Agreed. It's well-acted, no argument there, but this is clearly done to try and:
a. Establish Spuffy again
b. Potentially prep JM for a Spike spin-off

To have Buffy feeling for her abuser/rapist gives me the ick.
 
Last edited:
NotASlayer
NotASlayer
Regarding the acting, I think, in terms of post-Buffy/Angel work, JM is seriously underappreciated.
@NotASlayer I don't want to get this off topic but did want to respond quick to your reply above - I agree. He, ASH and SMG were the standouts from BTVS. The fact that JM didn't have a bigger career is a real shame.
 
NotASlayer
NotASlayer
If nothing else, he should have been the go-to actor for charismatic villain. I have seen him do that twice since watching Buffy/Angel - once opposite Charisma! - and possibly more before I knew who he was, because I saw him in other things.
Back
Top Bottom