Should the series have ended when season 6 was over?

I would classify that as one of the worst moments of the series. Buffy the victim being forced to feel for the man that almost raped her because he puts on a big dramatic pity me scene.

I found it more manipulative than a genuine ”big ol’ I’m sorry” (Which would have included not forcing himself back into Buffy’s life at this point. I’ll always feel he should have been moved to Angel first, then come back to Sunnydale… but obviously this didnt work for story reasons etc. But if they’d had more time, Spike should have given Buffy space, not become her dependant)
that's an interesting perspective. to me he so clearly felt acute agony for what he did to her. the pathos in that scene spoke volumes to me. but people are very divided on this clearly. i read Marsters had to go into therapy over the attempted rape scene . IMO it never should have happened
 
. i read Marsters had to go into therapy over the attempted rape scene . IMO it never should have happened
Honestly, I feel so bad for him. He seems like such a nice guy, and to have to do that… to his credit, acting wise, it is a very strong performance from both of them.

Yeah, it is very divisive. But that is also why I like the show, it invites different takes and perspectives. Which is why we’re still discussing it all these years later! 🙂
 
I would classify that as one of the worst moments of the series. Buffy the victim being forced to feel for the man that almost raped her because he puts on a big dramatic pity me scene.

I found it more manipulative than a genuine ”big ol’ I’m sorry” (Which would have included not forcing himself back into Buffy’s life at this point. I’ll always feel he should have been moved to Angel first, then come back to Sunnydale… but obviously this didnt work for story reasons etc. But if they’d had more time, Spike should have given Buffy space, not become her dependant)
it also wouldn't work for network reasons. And didn't she track him down leading to that scene. In fact her stumbling on or intentionally going to get him was very common in season 7, likely to the very this you're saying it does
 
it also wouldn't work for network reasons. And didn't she track him down leading to that scene. In fact her stumbling on or intentionally going to get him was very common in season 7, likely to the very this you're saying it does

He knows she is going to follow, that is the manipulation part. He is not putting on that show for himself. And yes, that is part of what is messed up about s7 and how it glorifies this continually abusive relationship that only continues to isolate Buffy from everyone else. She becomes the responsible caregiver for him, it is really messed up

But of course there are network reasons, I am just speaking my preference how they could have saved / made better this character and the relationship
 
He knows she is going to follow, that is the manipulation part. He is not putting on that show for himself. And yes, that is part of what is messed up about s7 and how it glorifies this continually abusive relationship that only continues to isolate Buffy from everyone else. She becomes the responsible caregiver for him, it is really messed up

But of course there are network reasons, I am just speaking my preference how they could have saved / made better this character and the relationship
well the words are because he was actually talking to her so he wouldn't be speaking out loud, but I can sure as hell see him doing to cross buring while alone

also, I believe the First is appearing to him as Buffy at times during this so expecting him to know how Buffy is going to act is not that easy
 
well the words are because he was actually talking to her so he wouldn't be speaking out loud, but I can sure as hell see him doing to cross buring while alone

also, I believe the First is appearing to him as Buffy at times during this so expecting him to know how Buffy is going to act is not that easy

I guess we can only agree to disagree.

I still find it an unforgivable plot because it is a recycled plot to boot (though this isn't the unforgivable plot thread I realize)

Still it is Bangel 2.0 (Angel coming back from hell and Buffy becoming his caretaker), which means not only that they're just re-using old ideas, but worse - Buffy as a character here is either shown to at best have regressed, at worst not learned anything at all from season 3.

Part of the point the first time they used the plot, to my mind, is that Buffy is feeling guilty for killing Angel and this, and her feelings for him, cloud her judgement. But the adults (and Xander to some extent) in her life, once it is revealed, point out that she made the wrong choice. She should not have hid Angel's return from them, she should not be his caretaker. And a big part of season 3 is ending Bangel, with even the Mayor chiming in about how an immortal-mortal relationship won't work out in the long run. I.e. Buffy should have learned from these things as a character.

Yet Buffy season 7, supposedly a mature young woman, is shown through this plot to double down on previously destructive behaviors. Not only does she put herself in a caretaker position again, she does so in an even worse position (her guilt is questionable here) and puts others at risk while doing so (again, and yet again even worse because she brings this danger into her house). She is not longer a love struck teenager, people love pointing out that Spuffy is supposedly the mature relationship (because of the sex), but this shows that Buffy has not matured at all. Again, she has either regressed or not learned at all from previous experiences. In fact, she doubles down as mentioned, and chooses to isolate herself even further from the others, in a way she did not in season 3.

So, to further a Spike plot, Buffy is undermined and regressed. In sum, yes, the series would have been better off ending in season 6, before they were completely out of ideas and still actually had an arc they were taking the lead character on. I may not love Buffy's depression season, but at least they are exploring Buffy and her trauma there.

Perhaps if they had ended in season 6 there could've been a Spike spin-off, with a hiatus during Angel season 4, and then getting a souled Spike to Angel somehow using that show as a backdoor pilot.
 
Still it is Bangel 2.0 (Angel coming back from hell and Buffy becoming his caretaker), which means not only that they're just re-using old ideas, but worse - Buffy as a character here is either shown to at best have regressed, at worst not learned anything at all from season 3.

I would say more like Bangel 0.5 as in their attempts to make Spuffy not Bangel 2.0 they made it, and Buffy, worse.

people love pointing out that Spuffy is supposedly the mature relationship (because of the sex),

Claiming that sex makes a relationship mature sounds like the teenage boy method of trying to convince a teenage girl to sleep with him, "because it's what mature people do." Which is extremely immature. I would therefore disagree with anyone pointing that out as a sign of "maturity."

Perhaps if they had ended in season 6 there could've been a Spike spin-off, with a hiatus during Angel season 4, and then getting a souled Spike to Angel somehow using that show as a backdoor pilot.

Season 5 of Angel showed that Buffy and Buffy and Angel would have been better served by Spike leaving Buffy at the end of season 4, when he should have been run out of town.
 
I guess we can only agree to disagree.

I still find it an unforgivable plot because it is a recycled plot to boot (though this isn't the unforgivable plot thread I realize)

Still it is Bangel 2.0 (Angel coming back from hell and Buffy becoming his caretaker), which means not only that they're just re-using old ideas, but worse - Buffy as a character here is either shown to at best have regressed, at worst not learned anything at all from season 3.

Part of the point the first time they used the plot, to my mind, is that Buffy is feeling guilty for killing Angel and this, and her feelings for him, cloud her judgement. But the adults (and Xander to some extent) in her life, once it is revealed, point out that she made the wrong choice. She should not have hid Angel's return from them, she should not be his caretaker. And a big part of season 3 is ending Bangel, with even the Mayor chiming in about how an immortal-mortal relationship won't work out in the long run. I.e. Buffy should have learned from these things as a character.

Yet Buffy season 7, supposedly a mature young woman, is shown through this plot to double down on previously destructive behaviors. Not only does she put herself in a caretaker position again, she does so in an even worse position (her guilt is questionable here) and puts others at risk while doing so (again, and yet again even worse because she brings this danger into her house). She is not longer a love struck teenager, people love pointing out that Spuffy is supposedly the mature relationship (because of the sex), but this shows that Buffy has not matured at all. Again, she has either regressed or not learned at all from previous experiences. In fact, she doubles down as mentioned, and chooses to isolate herself even further from the others, in a way she did not in season 3.

So, to further a Spike plot, Buffy is undermined and regressed. In sum, yes, the series would have been better off ending in season 6, before they were completely out of ideas and still actually had an arc they were taking the lead character on. I may not love Buffy's depression season, but at least they are exploring Buffy and her trauma there.

Perhaps if they had ended in season 6 there could've been a Spike spin-off, with a hiatus during Angel season 4, and then getting a souled Spike to Angel somehow using that show as a backdoor pilot.

You think the show is showing that Buffy was wrong to be Angel's caretaker? I don't think that's the narrative. Angel would not have survived without someone, yet higher powers brought him back from hell, stopped him from walking into the sun and would give him a seer soon.

Angel's presence helped out Faith as a traitor, get Buffy to fight Faith before the big battle and Buffy feeding him her own blood led to having thr Slayer dream that helped her figure out how to take out the Mayor. And only after writing this did I realize how thoroughly they set up Angel against Faith

Now of the people saying she shouldn't have been with Angel. Well, let's start with the villains. The First Evil and Mayor Wilkins both believe Buffy and Angel both believe they should be apart. But they are villains.

Meanwhile of the rest the strongest voices are Giles, Joyce and Xander, and maybe to a lesser degree Willow

Giles betrays Buffy by inflicting the cruciamentum on her

Joyce tries to dismiss her own role in Buffy's being thrown out and will try to burn her at the stake(yeah yeah, she was possessed)

Xander and Willow betray their significant others, but t least Willow tries to put a stop to it IMO

Everyone trying to get Buffy to ditch Angel this year is a betrayer while Buffy is trying to be as loyal as possible

She was right to do that and everyone else was wrong to judge her for it
 
I would say more like Bangel 0.5 as in their attempts to make Spuffy not Bangel 2.0 they made it, and Buffy, worse.



Claiming that sex makes a relationship mature sounds like the teenage boy method of trying to convince a teenage girl to sleep with him, "because it's what mature people do." Which is extremely immature. I would therefore disagree with anyone pointing that out as a sign of "maturity."

I really loathe that argument that her 'relationship' with Spike (erm..first off, what 'relationship'? Dumpster sex?) was the most 'mature'. Spuffy fans were just lucky the series switched to UPN to see raunchier scenes - and sadly objectifying James in the process.

It's compared to Bangel's relationship, which doesn't even stack up. They were only able to have sex once - and that was her first time. Let's remove the curse for a moment for argument's sake and Bangel were able to have a regular relationship - WB weren't exactly going to show a 17/18 year old Buffy having sex up against a wall with Angel.

S7 wasn't a relationship either. She was coddling her rapist and he was again isolating her from her loved ones.


Season 5 of Angel showed that Buffy and Buffy and Angel would have been better served by Spike leaving Buffy at the end of season 4, when he should have been run out of town.
Amen to that!


And just responding to this from earlier:
NotASlayer If nothing else, he should have been the go-to actor for charismatic villain. I have seen him do that twice since watching Buffy/Angel - once opposite Charisma! - and possibly more before I knew who he was, because I saw him in other things.
He does seem to get cast as villains 98% of the time. You could see him being a villain in a popular series like Game of Thrones/The White Lotus etc.
 
S7 wasn't a relationship either. She was coddling her rapist and he was again isolating her from her loved ones.

With Bangel, Buffy was, eventually, able to make the, hard, decision to kill the man she loved. With Spuffy, Buffy was unable to deal with Spike, a man even Spike eventually realised she did not love, even though he was a threat. That is not a mature relationship but a victim-abuser relationship. Something that results in Selfless making her into a raging hypocrite and Xander should have thrown that in her face later in the season. Which I guess he was too nice to do.
 
With Bangel, Buffy was, eventually, able to make the, hard, decision to kill the man she loved. With Spuffy, Buffy was unable to deal with Spike, a man even Spike eventually realised she did not love, even though he was a threat. That is not a mature relationship but a victim-abuser relationship. Something that results in Selfless making her into a raging hypocrite and Xander should have thrown that in her face later in the season. Which I guess he was too nice to do.
Well said.
I do appreciate the most mature thing she did in all of s7 - the 'cookie dough' speech.
 
My headcanon is that the Slayer is not a creature of the darkness, but a spirit of great love, and that's why Buffy is so effective as a Slayer and keeps coming back to life. Because the true quality of a hero is to be selfless and loving. If she demonstrates a superhuman capacity to forgive both Angel and Spike, well, yes. Superhuman.
 
My headcanon is that the Slayer is not a creature of the darkness, but a spirit of great love, and that's why Buffy is so effective as a Slayer and keeps coming back to life. Because the true quality of a hero is to be selfless and loving. If she demonstrates a superhuman capacity to forgive both Angel and Spike, well, yes. Superhuman.

Forgiving an abuser who is dead, regrets what he did, is no longer abusing you or whom you have got away from may be a sign of great love. Forgiving your abuser, who is blaming you for what he did and still abusing you, separating you from your family and friends and who you are still trapped with is a sign of being broken by that abuse. There is a major difference between the two, and it is the latter that is portrayed. If Spike had not blamed Buffy, preferably apologised and had left her alone, it would be the first. He did not. And if Buffy was capable of great love and forgiveness, Faith should have been forgiven by that logic.
 
Forgiving an abuser who is dead, regrets what he did, is no longer abusing you or whom you have got away from may be a sign of great love. Forgiving your abuser, who is blaming you for what he did and still abusing you, separating you from your family and friends and who you are still trapped with is a sign of being broken by that abuse. There is a major difference between the two, and it is the latter that is portrayed. If Spike had not blamed Buffy, preferably apologised and had left her alone, it would be the first. He did not. And if Buffy was capable of great love and forgiveness, Faith should have been forgiven by that logic.

look at her reaction to Faith waking up in season 4. It's not till after she steals her body that she really sets against her
 
Back to the thread's main question. Buffy the Vampire Slayer should have ended in season 4 with Spike getting staked rather than being a brain-chipped creep stalking Buffy, Joyce dying, Buffy dropping out of college to help Dawn financially, and then helping potential slayers before Sunnydale goes bye-bye. I'm not too into shows lasting more than 3-4 seasons long.
 
Back to the thread's main question. Buffy the Vampire Slayer should have ended in season 4 with Spike getting staked rather than being a brain-chipped creep stalking Buffy, Joyce dying, Buffy dropping out of college to help Dawn financially, and then helping potential slayers before Sunnydale goes bye-bye. I'm not too into shows lasting more than 3-4 seasons long.

Shows have a habit of peaking in season three, then going downhill from that point. Season one is invariably shaky, season two sees things coming together then season three tends to be where it clicks.

Now, I actually like season five, but even then I can admit it is pushing the bounds of the concept of the series. It's getting too serious, there are few standalone episodes that are actually fun to watch on their own, the tumour arc is far too realistic for a supernatural show and Spike's stalking and abuse is awful, yet played for laughs (by the show) or romanticised (by some fans). But for a final season ending in the character's death, I guess the level of seriousness is merited, but after that the show needed to stop pushing the bounds and return to what made it great. Instead, it was pushed under a high speed train.
 
Shows have a habit of peaking in season three, then going downhill from that point. Season one is invariably shaky, season two sees things coming together then season three tends to be where it clicks.

Now, I actually like season five, but even then I can admit it is pushing the bounds of the concept of the series. It's getting too serious, there are few standalone episodes that are actually fun to watch on their own, the tumour arc is far too realistic for a supernatural show and Spike's stalking and abuse is awful, yet played for laughs (by the show) or romanticised (by some fans). But for a final season ending in the character's death, I guess the level of seriousness is merited, but after that the show needed to stop pushing the bounds and return to what made it great. Instead, it was pushed under a high speed train.
Many TV shows have a general 5-year plan. After that, things can go off the rails..
I'm not sure ending the series at s4 would've been effective for the series.

I really love s5, minus a couple of things. The Gift was great television and I think a fitting way to end the series.
 
They probably should have done S6 like S6 of DS9, where the Stages of Grieving arc is resolved within six episodes, then return focus on episodic television to get a better idea of what works for the UPN era. Especially, if UPN wanted the series to last for a few extra years and serve as a cornerstone of the Network's teen block.

I would have spun Spike off at this point. Morally irredeemable characters were only a year or two from taking off. Give Spike a familiar, maybe show his efforts to dominate the Supernatural of another place. The character doesn't have a lot of stories left to tell.
 
BTVS's season 5 triggered me hard.

Writers gradually making Spuffy more serious made me gag. That Buffybot just made me go... are these writers for real??? Is this fanfic-level slop happening on a television episode???

Willow annoyed me. I feel sorry for sweet Tara dealing with Willow's bitter side that was growing. Not going away. Tara, I'll come rescue you from Willow and we could fall in love with each other instead. I'm down. That's what I was thinking.

Xander didn't stop being a red flag. I was like... Anya, you deserve better than Xander. This will not end well for you. Please get away to save yourself from heartbreak.

Dracula could have been written better. A character with the same name was arguably sexier, dangerously smarter, and emotionally captivating in this show:


Glory kept yapping about woe is me like a toxic narcissist would while threatening innocent lives just so she could go to another place. I got no sympathy nor patience for her.

Riley going to a brothel just made me feel like skipping the whole episode.

I could keep going on. But I'm about to sleep.
 
hoponlilmama
hoponlilmama
The issue is all of Spike's creepiness is mostly played for laughs.
Writers gradually making Spuffy more serious made me gag. That Buffybot just made me go... are these writers for real??? Is this fanfic-level slop happening on a television episode???

The Buffybot is deep fake p*rn taken to the nth level. I know that didn't exist back then, but it is utterly creepy when you take just a moment to think about it. Spuffy is just awful from start to finish. There is no way Spike should have survived season 5 as there were multiple times when there is no in-universe reason he isn't a pile of dust - he should have been run out of town after season 4 anyway at the very least. No "falling in love" - twisted Slayer obsession becoming even more twisted as he wasn't able to get his satisfaction from killing her - and have him skipping between Angel and Buffy causing random chaos on both series until finally joining Angel.

Dracula could have been written better. A character with the same name was arguably sexier, dangerously smarter, and emotionally captivating in this show:

Both my signature and avatar may be currently from the episode but Buffy vs Dracula just doesn't work for me. I don't know why, but it doesn't. Which is a shame as it is one of only a handful of episodes in that season that work on their own.
 
Anyanka Bunny Slayer
Anyanka Bunny Slayer
You can spell out 'porn' this isn't A Handmaid's Tale 😄
Back
Top Bottom