Should the series have ended when season 6 was over?

The Buffybot is deep fake p*rn taken to the nth level. I know that didn't exist back then, but it is utterly creepy when you take just a moment to think about it. Spuffy is just awful from start to finish. There is no way Spike should have survived season 5 as there were multiple times when there is no in-universe reason he isn't a pile of dust - he should have been run out of town after season 4 anyway at the very least. No "falling in love" - twisted Slayer obsession becoming even more twisted as he wasn't able to get his satisfaction from killing her - and have him skipping between Angel and Buffy causing random chaos on both series until finally joining Angel.
Well, Joss Whedon made things that didn't exist back then. So, there's that.

From my observation, it's about keeping Spike around for comic relief even though he should've been staked long ago. I have a hard time laughing. But I laughed after hearing this from Spike:

"(As Rachel) How can I thank you, you mysterious black-clad hunk of a night thing?
(As Angel) No need, little lady, your tears of gratitude are enough for me. You see, I was once a badass vampire, but love and a pesky curse defanged me. And now, I'm just a big, fluffy puppy with bad teeth. No, not the hair. Never the hair.
(As Rachel) But there must be some way I can show my appreciation?
(As Angel) No, helping those in need's my job, and workin' up a load of sexual tension and prancing away like a magnificent poof is truly thanks enough.
(As Rachel) I understand. I have a nephew who's gay, so...
(As Angel) *Gasps* Say no more. Evil's still afoot. And I'm almost out of that nancy-boy hair-gel I like so much. Quickly, to the Angel-mobile, away."

It still makes me laugh. But I think they should have left Spike be unresurrected and use another character for comic relief in Angel instead.

Both my signature and avatar may be currently from the episode but Buffy vs Dracula just doesn't work for me. I don't know why, but it doesn't. Which is a shame as it is one of only a handful of episodes in that season that work on their own.
Dracula has lived much longer than Buffy. It's an unfair advantage, you could say? Or maybe because it's a crossover between different realms of fiction that don't mix well together?
 
From my observation, it's about keeping Spike around for comic relief even though he should've been staked long ago. I have a hard time laughing. But I laughed after hearing this from Spike:

"(As Rachel) How can I thank you, you mysterious black-clad hunk of a night thing?
(As Angel) No need, little lady, your tears of gratitude are enough for me. You see, I was once a badass vampire, but love and a pesky curse defanged me. And now, I'm just a big, fluffy puppy with bad teeth. No, not the hair. Never the hair.
(As Rachel) But there must be some way I can show my appreciation?
(As Angel) No, helping those in need's my job, and workin' up a load of sexual tension and prancing away like a magnificent poof is truly thanks enough.
(As Rachel) I understand. I have a nephew who's gay, so...
(As Angel) *Gasps* Say no more. Evil's still afoot. And I'm almost out of that nancy-boy hair-gel I like so much. Quickly, to the Angel-mobile, away."

It still makes me laugh. But I think they should have left Spike be unresurrected and use another character for comic relief in Angel instead.

Although scenes like that one do show that Spike, and BtVS, would have been better served by shifting Spike to Angel earlier, before he had a chance to turn Buffy the Vampire Slayer into Spike the Slayer Layer (thanks to @Last Watcher for that term!). Having Spike be the most important character of the last two seasons was a major mistake.

Dracula has lived much longer than Buffy. It's an unfair advantage, you could say? Or maybe because it's a crossover between different realms of fiction that don't mix well together?

Maybe? I am just not sure. Like Superstar, for me it just doesn't work.
 
Although scenes like that one do show that Spike, and BtVS, would have been better served by shifting Spike to Angel earlier, before he had a chance to turn Buffy the Vampire Slayer into Spike the Slayer Layer (thanks to @Last Watcher for that term!). Having Spike be the most important character of the last two seasons was a major mistake.
After The Initiative business was over, Angel could have done something in LA. It would incentivize Spike to be in the Angel series. BTVS could have had a different comic relief character be as good or better than Spike after season 4. Not turn into this Spuffy the Dumpsterfire Teamplayer show.
Maybe? I am just not sure. Like Superstar, for me it just doesn't work.
I see.
 
They probably should have done S6 like S6 of DS9, where the Stages of Grieving arc is resolved within six episodes, then return focus on episodic television to get a better idea of what works for the UPN era. Especially, if UPN wanted the series to last for a few extra years and serve as a cornerstone of the Network's teen block.

I would have spun Spike off at this point. Morally irredeemable characters were only a year or two from taking off. Give Spike a familiar, maybe show his efforts to dominate the Supernatural of another place. The character doesn't have a lot of stories left to tell.
This is an interesting idea - do you mean give Spike a spin-off at the beginning or end of s6?
I'm not sure it would've worked though, considering AtS was running, but it's certainly an interesting thought.
 
@hoponlilmama, previous shows I watched did the creep factor for giggles. But I already experienced it beforehand. That's why I didn't find it amusing much when they had Spike be creepy for a humorous effect.
Good looking people get a pass when it comes to creepy/dangerous behaviour.

For example, put a lesser attractive person in place of Spike. Say it was Jonathan doing all those things. Or a random ugly demon. People would be crying for Buffy to kill or kick their butt.
 
Good looking people get a pass when it comes to creepy/dangerous behaviour.

For example, put a lesser attractive person in place of Spike. Say it was Jonathan doing all those things. Or a random ugly demon. People would be crying for Buffy to kill or kick their butt.

Yes, if the only thing you changed about Spike was his appearance - not his accent, way of speaking or attire - so that he looked like this

1x10_006.jpg


his behaviour would suddenly become horrific, not romantic. And with the improvement in video editing technology, it is now possible to prove that.
 
hoponlilmama
hoponlilmama
Exactly!
Good looking people get a pass when it comes to creepy/dangerous behaviour.

For example, put a lesser attractive person in place of Spike. Say it was Jonathan doing all those things. Or a random ugly demon. People would be crying for Buffy to kill or kick their butt.
Not me. Not everyone gives physically attractive people a chance when they got the creep factor going on. Picky people like me have a challenging time finding shows to watch since we don't tolerate things like this. I pay attention to a person's mind much more than their physical appearance and sexual convenience. And I'm a thinker. Not a doer as much. So, that could explain it as well.
 
Not me. Not everyone gives physically attractive people a chance when they got the creep factor going on. Picky people like me have a challenging time finding shows to watch since we don't tolerate things like this. I pay attention to a person's mind much more than their physical appearance and sexual convenience. And I'm a thinker. Not a doer as much. So, that could explain it as well.
I agree!!!
hoponlilmama said:


Good looking people get a pass when it comes to creepy/dangerous behaviour.

For example, put a lesser attractive person in place of Spike. Say it was Jonathan doing all those things. Or a random ugly demon. People would be crying for Buffy to kill or kick their butt.
Nope. I actually cried a bit when the demon Merl (from Angel) got murdered by humans... Merl Arguably those humans were 'more' and better than a 'demon', but Merl was way nicer and more decent, IMO.

I actually am one of those who would have preferred Jonathan for season 7 and think he would have been far more interesting than the idiot played by Tom Lenk. And Danny Strong is a much better actor... but sadly I think this was the time when Danny's career started to take off.

Please note that even though the trio were pretty damn evil at times, only Warren (who was a sociopath) actually met with death by a 'good guy' -- and that was NOT considered a 'justifiable homicide' by either her friends or the fandom. Willow is attractive. She's a main character. She's also detested by a significant number of fans (not just because she murdered people, but that doesn't add to the love)

If pretty people were all the rage, why would they have even given a short, nebbishy boy - Danny Strong (Jonathan) a whole episode of his own. Yes, he doesn't play a true hero and it raises interesting questions about the nature of celebrity but he's not exactly a 'handsome' star boy and he's not dead at the end of the episode though he probably caused people to die.

Considering all the stories I've read that have written a MUCH bigger part for Clem, who is considered ugly by many different standards BEFORE his scary face animals make an appearance... I think a lot of Buffy fans are different and able to do more than look at people as more than 'hot sex objects'.

Some of the nastier villains were pretty darn attractive too.

Yes, of course, the biological imperative makes most humans more interested in people who are healthy looking (shapely, well muscled, with symmetrical features and good conformation) because these GENETICALLY advantage us. People who are deformed looking often have genetic deficits. So... yes, we as a species are programmed to like people who fall within 'parameters'. Not at all good when that is ALL we value, but valuing it keeps our species alive. Healthy people survive and reproduce. Interestingly, when you have inbred populations, attractiveness goes way down... and apparently the possession of money and power doesn't seem to help fix this.

Anyway... I don't think the Buffy fandom is that shallow.

And objectively, Riley is better put together than Spike who is short, skinny (almost emaciated at times) and has a weak chin (may even be a chin implant!) But... he has mega presence as an actor and as a man... that is part of why he is attractive... not just physical symmetry and perfection. He actually goes against the 'typical' guy 'most' women are said to want (guys like Angel and Riley - big, tall, muscular) Spike is only one of these.

Yes, there's TV with 'normal looking people' as stars. If you prefer this approach, I recommend 'Britbox' or some other way of watching British TV. Yes, American TV is more driven by glamour and looks... and this is not a great thing... But honestly, when TV is done well, we end up with people who look like people becoming our heroes...

Anyone remember that it was Andy Sipowitz that saved NYPD blue, not that carrot haired glamourous fellow...

Yep, it should happen more. It really should. He's one of my favourite TV characters of all time.
 
If a person's mind is not healthy, their physical health gets negatively impacted in the future. That's not a good sign of long-term survival. I'm attracted to minds that will make them take care of the planet, other people, and themselves for keeping a healthy enough environment even though perfection isn't realistic.

Spike smoking makes me think about lung cancer. Not how cool it is. I've known people who died from cancer. Spike killing 2 slayers for the thrill of it makes me think of mothers grieving about their dead daughters. Not how cool it is. Spike almost having his way with Buffy in "Seeing Red" slightly reminds me of a formerly toxic relationship with my ex. I sought out therapy for that. Spike not holding himself accountable by blaming women reminds me of formerly toxic relationships I had, too. These were times when I was too young for my own good. But I've changed.
 
Last edited:
Spike and Clem are actually a great example of how appearance can influence opinions. Clem is liked, despite his appearance, because he is a genuinely nice guy; his behaviour trumps his appearance. Spike is liked, because of his appearance, because he is genuinely not a nice guy; his appearance trumps his behaviour, especially towards Buffy, which is that of an obsessed, narcissistic, abusive stalker.
 
Not me. Not everyone gives physically attractive people a chance when they got the creep factor going on. Picky people like me have a challenging time finding shows to watch since we don't tolerate things like this. I pay attention to a person's mind much more than their physical appearance and sexual convenience. And I'm a thinker. Not a doer as much. So, that could explain it as well.
Just depends on the individual - for some people, they're very vocal and bothered by it, and that's perfectly okay. Others let it slide - when they find the individual attractive.

I find Spike absolutely smoking hot - but his actions from s5 onwards? A definite NOT.

I've mentioned this example a number of times on the forum, but do you know of the series You? It starred Penn Badgley playing Joe Goldberg - a murderer and absolute creep. People were thirsting over Joe, and Penn had to publicly state to these people - you should not love this guy, you should not root for him.




Nope. I actually cried a bit when the demon Merl (from Angel) got murdered by humans... Merl Arguably those humans were 'more' and better than a 'demon', but Merl was way nicer and more decent, IMO.

I'm going to say yes. Most of the time (not ALL of the time) when a character is hot, the people that stan them will wave away their behaviour because of their looks.

I actually am one of those who would have preferred Jonathan for season 7 and think he would have been far more interesting than the idiot played by Tom Lenk. And Danny Strong is a much better actor... but sadly I think this was the time when Danny's career started to take off.
I 100% agree and it's not the first time I've said that I wish they'd kept Jonathan around instead of Tucker's brother for s7. But my example of Jonathan is in regards to replacing him with Spike and his creepy actions.

Imagine it was Jonathan breaking into Buffy's house to steal her clothes and underwear. It was him stalking her, he made a shrine of Buffy, he made a sexbot of her, kidnapped her, tried to kill her etc...
People would be immediately calling for his head.


Please note that even though the trio were pretty damn evil at times, only Warren (who was a sociopath) actually met with death by a 'good guy' -- and that was NOT considered a 'justifiable homicide' by either her friends or the fandom. Willow is attractive. She's a main character. She's also detested by a significant number of fans (not just because she murdered people, but that doesn't add to the love)

If pretty people were all the rage, why would they have even given a short, nebbishy boy - Danny Strong (Jonathan) a whole episode of his own. Yes, he doesn't play a true hero and it raises interesting questions about the nature of celebrity but he's not exactly a 'handsome' star boy and he's not dead at the end of the episode though he probably caused people to die.
As we discover, that was due to magic, that's why he gets the 'lead' in that particular episode. Not because Jonathan is some suave leading man or superhero. By the way, I don't really have any love for that episode (Superstar).


Considering all the stories I've read that have written a MUCH bigger part for Clem, who is considered ugly by many different standards BEFORE his scary face animals make an appearance... I think a lot of Buffy fans are different and able to do more than look at people as more than 'hot sex objects'.
There's Cluffy fic out there! Of course people are able to love characters and overlook their physical appearance, but we're discussing this in context of creepy behaviour. Clem's not the one stalking Buffy or pressuring her to have sex with him.

Some of the nastier villains were pretty darn attractive too.

Yes, of course, the biological imperative makes most humans more interested in people who are healthy looking (shapely, well muscled, with symmetrical features and good conformation) because these GENETICALLY advantage us. People who are deformed looking often have genetic deficits. So... yes, we as a species are programmed to like people who fall within 'parameters'. Not at all good when that is ALL we value, but valuing it keeps our species alive. Healthy people survive and reproduce. Interestingly, when you have inbred populations, attractiveness goes way down... and apparently the possession of money and power doesn't seem to help fix this.

Anyway... I don't think the Buffy fandom is that shallow.
This isn't restricted to Buffy only. People will excuse atrocious behaviour from certain characters because they're good looking. Like I said, it doesn't happen all the time, but it occurs often.

This bleeds into real life where they've done studies that show attractive people are considered more trustworthy, and have other positive qualities.

I don't think it's much of a stretch to say some of the fandom can be shallow. I still see comments to this day when on the discussion of Spike's action where they'll say: "I don't care, he's so hot LOL"


And objectively, Riley is better put together than Spike who is short, skinny (almost emaciated at times) and has a weak chin (may even be a chin implant!) But... he has mega presence as an actor and as a man... that is part of why he is attractive... not just physical symmetry and perfection. He actually goes against the 'typical' guy 'most' women are said to want (guys like Angel and Riley - big, tall, muscular) Spike is only one of these.

It all comes down to personal preference. Of the three you mentioned, Spike would be my top pick.
But ol' William not only had the looks but people dug the overall package - the bleached hair, the leather coat, the sexy accent. Maybe Riley needed to wear long leather jackets more? 😉

Yes, there's TV with 'normal looking people' as stars. If you prefer this approach, I recommend 'Britbox' or some other way of watching British TV. Yes, American TV is more driven by glamour and looks... and this is not a great thing... But honestly, when TV is done well, we end up with people who look like people becoming our heroes...
I just like good television. I don't decide on watching something because of how cute someone might be. 😂


Anyone remember that it was Andy Sipowitz that saved NYPD blue, not that carrot haired glamourous fellow...

Yep, it should happen more. It really should. He's one of my favourite TV characters of all time.
Great example.

But you can also look at the opposite end of the spectrum and bring up examples where someone wasn't considered good looking enough - Amy Schumer left the Barbie project because of the backlash. Gal Gadot received backlash on her looks when cast as Wonder Woman. Can you believe that? And she's absolutely stunning.
 
Just depends on the individual - for some people, they're very vocal and bothered by it, and that's perfectly okay. Others let it slide - when they find the individual attractive.

I find Spike absolutely smoking hot - but his actions from s5 onwards? A definite NOT.

I've mentioned this example a number of times on the forum, but do you know of the series You? It starred Penn Badgley playing Joe Goldberg - a murderer and absolute creep. People were thirsting over Joe, and Penn had to publicly state to these people - you should not love this guy, you should not root for him.
James Marsters was cute while handsome before looking like Spike from my experience. But after I saw him shirtless when penetrating Buffy's mouth with such passion from 5x04 on BTVS in his dream, that was hot. Still, it doesn't excuse Spike's soulless vampire actions. Writers can't be excused for their actions from seasons 5-7 when making the fanfic-level Spuffy slop. But I will mention that James Marsters looks arguably much better with his naturally curly and slightly darker hair:


You is a series that I never watched after watching too many Law & Order episodes. But I heard about it. Penn Badgley didn't make me thirsty at all. Guys who are a bit beefier do:

 
James Marsters was cute while handsome before looking like Spike from my experience. But after I saw him shirtless when penetrating Buffy's mouth with such passion from 5x04 on BTVS in his dream, that was hot. Still, it doesn't excuse Spike's soulless vampire actions. Writers can't be excused for their actions from seasons 5-7 when making the fanfic-level Spuffy slop. But I will mention that James Marsters looks arguably much better with his naturally curly and slightly darker hair:
Brown hair, bleached hair, his grey hair - it's all good to me! 😁
Spike was one of those characters who managed to have chemistry with everyone - I could see him in ships with a few different characters.


You is a series that I never watched after watching too many Law & Order episodes. But I heard about it. Penn Badgley didn't make me thirsty at all. Guys who are a bit beefier do:

Count me in as a Hugh Jackman lover!
 
Brown hair, bleached hair, his grey hair - it's all good to me! 😁
Spike was one of those characters who managed to have chemistry with everyone - I could see him in ships with a few different characters.
James Marsters was quite a seasoned actor who had his own Genesis Theatre Company group before playing Spike. That's a factor in how he was able to interact with other characters well. Anthony Head helped him learn how to master the English accent, too. Which is a plus to me at least.
Count me in as a Hugh Jackman lover!
🙂
 
People talking about some of Spike's actions towards Buffy when he fell for her, leading up to things in season 5. Spike was already a mass murderer, who'd killed two Slayers. That was all the reason anyone needed to call for his head. We obviously weren't getting it if he couldn't fight back, so what would even be the point of calling for it for these lesser offenses
 
James Marsters was quite a seasoned actor who had his own Genesis Theatre Company group before playing Spike. That's a factor in how he was able to interact with other characters well. Anthony Head helped him learn how to master the English accent, too. Which is a plus to me at least.

🙂
Apart from being talented, guy just oozes charisma. You either have it, or you don't!
 
all the responses are good but yours resonates with me in particular as i basically agree . the ending was a bit weird with the crone who apparently was around all this time but nobody ever knew it. just felt like the writers pulled it out of their azzes a bit. the spike/buffy stuff for me was spectacular. still pissed they killed off anya even though apparently emma wanted that. xander was very emotionless when he said 'that's my girl' which still makes me scratch my head. but hey pobody's nerfect

To be frank I thought the writing was terrible in Chosen. You literally have a voice over of Buffy talking about giving a choice while having a montage of women NOT given a choice 😄

Spike dying lost any emotional resonance as by that point people knew he was going over to Angel so would be back.

You could've killed Anya off in Selfless and not missed her for the rest of the season. At the time Joss when asked about the lack of mentioning her, he said it was late so he had to use short hand for Anya !
It's only recently that Emma said she bad big problems with Whedon and was leaving whether the show carried on or not. So the way he killed her off was maybe his payback to her like it was with Charisma putting her in a coma

Bur in answer to the question. I think Buffy ended in Season 5. He dying to save the world was the right way to end it imo
 
To be frank I thought the writing was terrible in Chosen. You literally have a voice over of Buffy talking about giving a choice while having a montage of women NOT given a choice 😄

Buffy had become what she was supposed to be against.

You could've killed Anya off in Selfless and not missed her for the rest of the season. At the time Joss when asked about the lack of mentioning her, he said it was late so he had to use short hand for Anya !
It's only recently that Emma said she bad big problems with Whedon and was leaving whether the show carried on or not. So the way he killed her off was maybe his payback to her like it was with Charisma putting her in a coma

I read an article that was apparently published prior to season 7 and in it Emma said she had already quit, but hoped her character wouldn't die. Which makes her apparently putting Anya forward to be killed seem odd, and Joss being spiteful seems much more likely. I have said it before, but in a show that was supposed to be about female characters, having three of your five main female actors quit or refuse to come back after S6 is a bad sign. By the end of Chosen, the show was no longer about female characters and female empowerment at all.

Bur in answer to the question. I think Buffy ended in Season 5. He dying to save the world was the right way to end it imo

Seasons six and seven are merely a nightmare caused by passing through the hell portal, in which she gets a glimpse of a universe only D'Hoffreyn and the Lower Beings would love.
 
Back
Top Bottom